laptop, notebook, cellphone, computer, desk, workspace, workplace, wireless technology, codes, coding, data, display, electronics, html, internet, keyboard, monitor, office, pen, screen, smartphone, technology, wireless, working, laptop, computer, coding, coding, coding, coding, coding
Photo by Pexels on Pixabay

Rules and ethics

Part of Business productivity software rules and ethics in the UK

Which UK rule checks each business productivity software statement

Match a business productivity software claim, marketing email, customer type and security statement to the UK rule that checks each, from CAP Code to CMA207.

This is an editorial pen name used by the publication, not a claim of an independently verified personal identity. Original editorial credit: Editorial Desk.

A software vendor makes four kinds of statement, and each meets a different UK rule. A product claim, a marketing email, a sale to a particular customer and a security statement are checked separately. Business productivity software suppliers who test them one by one avoid assuming that one compliant claim covers the rest.

The sources here are the CAP Code, the ICO's direct marketing guidance, the CMA's unfair commercial practices guidance (CMA207) and the government's security code for software vendors. They do not determine obligations for a product, seller or contract. Regulated sectors and overseas marketing require separate advice.

What to take away

  • A compliant marketing claim does not make an email list lawful, because delivery raises a different question.
  • Business customers and consumers sit under different rules, so classify the customer before applying either.
  • Security Code alignment is voluntary and non-statutory, so keep a record of what is in place and what is still planned.
  • Recheck the map whenever a claim, marketing route or sales model changes.

Claims fall under the CAP Code

Website copy and sales decks fall within the CAP Code. The Advertising Standards Authority (ASA) enforces it, and the Committee of Advertising Practice (CAP) writes it. Objective claims need evidence, comparisons need an appropriate basis, and marketing should be recognisable as marketing.

CAP also points business-to-business advertisers to the Business Protection from Misleading Marketing Regulations 2008. A claim aimed at companies therefore has a second rule set behind it. Before a feature claim goes live, keep its evidence in the same file as the copy.

A simple claim file helps. Give the objective claim, the comparison and the testimonial a line each, and record the supporting evidence beside it. A claim that is unproven and a claim that is hard to recognise as marketing are separate faults, and the file shows which one you have.

Emails raise a different question

A lawful claim can still be sent unlawfully. The way marketing reaches people is covered by ICO direct marketing guidance on UK GDPR and the Privacy and Electronic Communications Regulations 2003 (PECR). The ICO enforces these rules, so the channel decides what the sender must check.

Audience type, contact data and communication channel all matter. Neither check stands in for the other: a lawful list does not rescue a weak claim. Where contact details are personal information, data protection duties follow them from collection to deletion.

Consumers change the rule set

Consumer rules enter when the customer is an individual, not a company. The CMA's guidance on unfair commercial practices covers business conduct that the law on unfair business-to-consumer trading prohibits under the Digital Markets, Competition and Consumers Act 2024. It is not the general code for all business software sales.

Classification can be untidy. An individual plan, a sole trader's circumstances or mixed personal use may require the seller to classify the customer. An enterprise agreement between companies is not automatically governed by consumer rules, so read the plan type and the contract terms together.

Wider data, monitoring and ethics questions sit beside sales and belong under rules and ethics. The checks here stay narrower: they ask what a seller may say, and to whom.

A security statement is not a licence

The government's code for software vendors is voluntary. It is current guidance, not a statutory licence. The code contains 14 principles split across 4 themes, and they cover how vendors govern, design, build, test and maintain software products.

Alignment means a vendor can evidence the practices it has implemented. It does not mean the product is certified, approved or legally compliant. Any statement of alignment describes the vendor's own position, so keep the evidence behind it.

Before advertising compliance or alignment, write down the practices already in place and those still planned. Marketing should then say only what that record supports. Overstating alignment turns a security question back into a claims question under the CAP Code.

One map, five rows

What you are sayingRule that checks itWhere it comes from
An objective claim, comparison or testimonialCAP CodeWritten by CAP, enforced by the ASA
A claim aimed at companiesBusiness Protection from Misleading Marketing Regulations 2008Pointed to by CAP
A marketing email or other direct marketingUK GDPR and PECRICO guidance, enforced by the ICO
A claim aimed at individualsDigital Markets, Competition and Consumers Act 2024CMA207 guidance
A security or alignment statementSoftware Security Code of PracticeVoluntary government guidance

Finish the map by writing the activity, jurisdiction, customer type, data role, evidence owner and specialist needed on each row. A row without an evidence owner is a claim that nobody can defend when it is questioned.

Before you act

  • Put each objective claim, comparison and testimonial in a claim file with its evidence.
  • Check the channel and the contact data before any marketing email goes out.
  • Classify the customer before applying consumer or business rules.
  • List security practices in place and still planned before advertising alignment.
  • Recheck the map when a claim, marketing route or sales model changes.

Common questions

Does a compliant advert make a marketing email lawful?

No. The CAP Code addresses the claim, while ICO direct marketing guidance covers the delivery under UK GDPR and PECR. Audience type, contact data and channel decide the sender's checks, whatever the advert says.

Do the CMA's consumer rules cover every software sale?

No. The CMA guidance addresses business-to-consumer conduct and should not be presented as the general code for all business software sales. A sole trader or mixed personal use may need classification, and an enterprise agreement between companies is not automatically governed by consumer rules.

Is the Software Security Code of Practice a legal requirement?

No. It is voluntary and non-statutory. Alignment means a vendor can evidence the practices it has implemented, not that the product is certified, approved or legally compliant. Say only what the vendor's own record supports.

More in Rules and ethics