A diverse team collaborates in a modern office, using laptops and tablets for planning and brainstorming.
Photo by Yan Krukau on Pexels

Reviews

Part of How to compare eight productivity software tools before reaching a verdict

How to ask five productivity software providers for comparable quotes

How to ask five business productivity software providers for comparable written quotations: price per user, term, VAT, renewal uplift and setup.

This is an editorial pen name used by the publication, not a claim of an independently verified personal identity. Original editorial credit: Editorial Desk.

Seat-based plans are hard to compare unless the units match. A quotation from Microsoft Planner, Asana, Trello, monday work management or Notion Projects is only comparable once the named-user count, the term and the plan are fixed, so ask each provider for a dated written quotation on the same terms before comparing cost.

What to take away

  • Ask every provider for a dated written quotation, because list prices move.
  • A comparable quotation states the price per named user per month, the term, the VAT treatment, the renewal uplift and any implementation package.
  • Treat a missing line as a question to put in writing, never as a zero.
  • Name the plan on each quotation, because what a licence includes depends on it.
  • The five providers are candidates, not a ranking, and none paid for inclusion.

Why a dated quotation beats a list price

List prices move, and seat-based plans are hard to compare unless the units match. Ask each provider for a quotation dated when it is issued, so every figure can be traced to a day.

VAT belongs to that date. VAT rates can change, so a quotation should say which treatment it applies. A price quoted without VAT and one quoted with it cannot share a column, and a missing note leaves the buyer to guess. Put every figure on one basis before comparing.

GOV.UK says you usually charge the standard rate of VAT, currently 20%, on most goods and services. To move an exclusive price to the inclusive basis, multiply by 1.2. To strip VAT from an inclusive price, divide by 1.2. Apply one of the two to every quoted figure.

The five lines every quotation must state

Every quotation should state five lines: the price per named user per month, the term, the VAT treatment, the renewal uplift and any implementation package. A quotation missing one of them is incomplete, not cheap.

LineAsk the provider to stateGap to watch
Price per named user per monthA unit price and the number of named users it assumesA single total that hides the unit
TermThe contract length and how it endsTwo prices on different terms
VAT treatmentWhether each figure includes or excludes VATMixed bases in one comparison
Renewal upliftThe change at renewal, in writingA low first-term price with no stated uplift
Implementation packageWhat setup, support and change work it coversImplementation priced outside the quotation

Treat the missing line as a question, not as a zero. If a provider leaves out the implementation package, ask whether setup is included, priced separately or not offered, and record the written answer beside the quotation. Do the same for renewal uplift, where silence is a risk of its own. A software budget template keeps the units and tax visible.

What each provider's quotation must pin down

Each provider's plan decides what the licence includes, so the quotation has to name the plan and not only the product. Microsoft's service description warns that availability varies by plan, which makes the exact licence the first line to confirm.

ProviderSettle in writing with the quotation
Microsoft PlannerThe exact licence, guest access and export
AsanaPlan-level administration, collaborator visibility and how a finished project leaves the service
TrelloThe plan limits and the export route
monday work managementWhich edition carries the controls, and who maintains columns and automations
Notion ProjectsPermission inheritance, template governance and search under the quoted plan

These points come from the first-party documentation each provider publishes, not from a trial, and no account or plan was tested. Treat each as a question for the quotation, not a finding. Candidates are first drawn from first-party records, as in the four-tool shortlist.

Putting the quotations side by side

Quotations compare only when every provider prices the same scenario. Fix the named-user count, the term and the plan first, then log why each option passed or failed in the selection checklist.

  1. Fix the named-user count, the term and one realistic scenario, and send them to every provider.
  2. Confirm the exact licence and plan limits in writing.
  3. Test access control, ownership transfer, reporting and export on that plan.
  4. Price the licence, implementation, support and change work on one basis.

A scenario with real deadlines, a guest, a leaver and one exception makes the third step meaningful. Planner, Asana and Trello can share one workflow, so a product comparison of the three helps when you write the test cases.

What a quotation will not show

A quotation prices the service but not the terms around it. Liability and exit sit in the contract, so read a software contract alongside the quotation before you sign.

Keep the dated quotation, the written answers to your missing-line questions and the scenario results in one file. If a provider will not confirm a line in writing, that refusal is part of the comparison.

Common questions

Which five providers does this compare?

Microsoft Planner, Asana, Trello, monday work management and Notion Projects. Each publishes first-party documentation detailed enough to frame a trial question.

What should a quotation always include?

The price per named user per month, the term, the VAT treatment, the renewal uplift and any implementation package, with the date it was issued.

How do I compare cost fairly?

Ask for a dated quotation using identical units, term and renewal uplift across all five. The full cost across five stages goes beyond the first term.

More in Reviews